Training Day ← Second Hour ← Activity

🔍 Activity: Is This a Good Prompt?

Below are 8 different prompts — vote on whether each is good or needs improvement, then discuss with your group: Why? And what would make it better?

⏱ 10 Minutes 👥 Group Discussion
💡
How to evaluate a prompt?

Ask yourself: Does the model know what I want? For whom? In what style? And what is the required format? The clearer the answers, the stronger the prompt.

📋 The Eight Prompts

1
📧 Task: Writing an email
Write an email
Your opinion:
💬 What information is missing? If you sent it now — what would the model write?
2
📊 Task: Summarizing a report
Summarize this report into 5 concise points in a formal administrative style, highlighting any key numbers or recommendations. The report is directed at project managers.
Your opinion:
💬 What are the elements of this prompt? Do you find anything that could be added to make it stronger?
3
🎓 Task: Explaining a concept
Explain artificial intelligence in a very simple, scientific, detailed, short, easy way that is suitable for everyone.
Your opinion:
💬 What is the problem with this prompt despite its length? Can "very simple" and "detailed" go together?
4
💼 Task: Preparing a job description
You are an HR manager at a tech startup. Write a job description for a "Data Analyst" position targeted at candidates with 3-5 years of experience, including required skills and the benefits offered by the company, in a professional and engaging style.
Your opinion:
💬 Which framework does this prompt use? Do you think the model will need any further clarification?
5
📱 Task: Social media content
Write a LinkedIn post about a successful project we completed.
Your opinion:
💬 This prompt contains some information — but what prevents it from getting a good result? What would you add if you were writing it?
6
🔍 Task: Data analysis
I find it difficult to present sales data to my manager in a convincing way — they always ask for more details after presentations. Suggest 3 ways to present Q3 data more clearly and persuasively.
Your opinion:
💬 Which framework is this prompt similar to? Does the personal context ("I find it difficult") help or complicate things?
7
📝 Task: Writing training content
You are a professional trainer with 10 years of experience training government employees. Write an introductory leaflet about Microsoft Copilot for a group of employees who have never heard of it before, in a friendly, non-technical style, in 4 short paragraphs, mentioning one use case related to reporting.
Your opinion:
💬 What elements does this prompt contain? Is there anything extra or missing?
8
🤖 Task: Open request
Help me.
Your opinion:
💬 This is the shortest prompt possible — is it always wrong? When is "Help me" enough?

Voted on 0 of 8 prompts

📊 Voting Summary
0
✅ Good
0
❌ Needs Improvement
0
🤔 So-so